With social care struggling to fill vacancies, robust recruitment checks are vital to protecting vulnerable people from abuse and fraud, writes Melissa Sorenson of the Professional Background Screening Association.

Recent incidents of fraud within social care serve as a reminder of the importance of robust employment screening and ongoing safeguarding measures. In October, Derbyshire Police reported a supported housing manager had been jailed after stealing more than £55,000 from two vulnerable service users.
As Social Care Today recently reported, vacancies have fallen to their lowest level in a decade, yet workforce growth is slowing. With approximately 96,000 vacant posts across adult social care in England, providers continue to face considerable recruitment and retention pressures.
Understandably, employers want to get people into roles quickly. However, the challenge is ensuring the urgency to fill vacancies does not compromise the quality of recruitment decisions or the safeguarding of vulnerable individuals.
Looking beyond the DBS check
In my view, one of the biggest risks is treating employment screening as a series of isolated compliance, or worse, check-the-box exercises rather than a comprehensive approach to establishing someone’s suitability for a role. A Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) check is an essential safeguarding measure where applicable, but it cannot establish whether someone has fabricated their employment history, misrepresented their qualifications or is working under another person’s identity.
Employers should independently verify employment references and relevant qualifications, establish a candidate’s identity, undertake appropriate right-to-work checks and investigate unexplained employment gaps sensitively.
Technology can support these processes, particularly as sophisticated document manipulation and artificial intelligence make fraudulent applications increasingly convincing. However, technology should complement, rather than replace, professional judgement.
Closing the gaps in temporary staffing
Social care’s reliance on agency workers introduces another layer of complexity. When recruitment is outsourced, providers must have confidence that appropriate checks have been completed and that the individual arriving for a shift is the person who was screened.
In England, the Care Quality Commission’s Regulation 19 extends to agency and bank staff, among others, reinforcing providers’ responsibilities. Regular audits of recruitment partners, clear contractual screening requirements and appropriate identity verification at the point of deployment can help reduce vulnerabilities.
Safeguarding beyond the job offer
Screening should not be viewed solely as a pre-employment activity. Circumstances can change throughout an individual’s employment, and a satisfactory background check cannot guarantee future conduct.
Proportionate ongoing checks, monitoring professional registrations where applicable, effective supervision and accessible whistleblowing procedures can help employers identify emerging concerns. These measures must be lawful, transparent and appropriate to the responsibilities and risks associated with each role.
Supporting recruitment and retention
Importantly, stronger screening does not have to mean slower recruitment. Clear communication, efficient verification processes and early engagement with candidates can reduce unnecessary delays and improve the onboarding experience. Nor should heightened awareness of fraud create a culture of suspicion. The overwhelming focus should remain on supporting genuine candidates and building a trusted, professional workforce.
Safer recruitment can also contribute to retention by protecting existing employees from the additional pressures associated with unsuitable appointments and repeated recruitment cycles.
For social care providers outsourcing their pre-employment screening, choosing a reputable, accredited screening partner is equally important. The sector is built on trust. Establishing that trust should begin before someone enters the workplace and continue throughout their employment.
Melissa Sorenson is the Executive Director, Professional Background Screening Association

Images: Melissa Sorenson and Tim Gouw/UnSplash
In related news:
Fuel poverty takes toll on health, particularly respiratory conditions
Leave a Reply