Breaking the Cycle: How high staff turnover threatens care quality
Just over a week ago we heard from Susanne Jeffries who discussed the impact the social care staffing crisis is having on managers. This week she takes a different angle.
The social care sector is facing an unprecedented workforce crisis, with the issue set to increase significantly over the next 10 years. This high turnover rate has created a damaging cycle that compromises the care quality provided to some of our most vulnerable individuals, while simultaneously pushing the care workforce to physical and emotional limits. Staff shortages, exacerbated by financial constraints, an aging population, and the COVID-19 pandemic, have become more than a logistical issue; they represent a systemic challenge that demands urgent attention.
In this article, we’ll explore how a high staff turnover rate creates a cycle that undermines the quality of care, impacts employee well-being, and what the sector can do to begin breaking free of it.
Understanding the cycle: How staff shortages fuel staff turnover
In the world of adult social care, the typical workload is inherently demanding. Care workers and managers are tasked with supporting individuals who require support, often with limited resources. However, when staff members leave these challenges are amplified
1. Increased Workload
- When staff leave, those remaining have to take on additional responsibilities to ensure that basic care needs are met. Managers and frontline care workers are required to cover shifts, resulting in longer working hours and less time for critical activities such as training, care planning, and team development.
2. Reduced Morale
- As workloads increase, employee morale tends to drop. The physical and emotional toll of overwork, coupled with the lack of adequate support, causes frustration and burnout, often prompting other workers to consider leaving as well.
3. Compromised care quality
- When staff are overburdened and fatigued, the quality of care they provide naturally suffers. Although frontline workers and managers strive to deliver compassionate care, the demands of covering additional shifts and tasks compromise the ability to offer individualised, high-quality care.
4. Reputation and retention issues
- When care quality declines, it can affect a provider’s reputation, making it difficult to attract new staff and retain current employees. Prospective employees may be wary of working in a challenging environment with high turnover rates, while existing staff members may seek out more stable, less demanding roles elsewhere.
This cycle is self-perpetuating and shows no sign of slowing down without intervention. A high turnover rate not only contributes to staffing shortages, but it also compromises care quality and exacerbates burnout among managers and staff.
The Impact on care quality: Struggling to meet standards
Under the Health and Care Act 2022, care providers in the UK are required to meet regulatory standards for quality and safety. However, with ongoing staff shortages, maintaining these standards becomes a herculean task.
Managers, who are responsible for ensuring the safety and effectiveness of care delivery, are often forced to work in crisis mode. Instead of focusing on strategic oversight and improving care quality, they are consumed by day-to-day operational issues, such as shift cover, recruitment and induction. This reactive approach can lead to lapses in compliance, safety concerns, and a reduction in the overall standard of care provided. The research highlights that managers can spend up to 80% of their time dealing with staffing issues, which leaves limited capacity to carry out quality-focused initiatives and may place facilities at risk of non-compliance during.
Moreover, when facilities are short-staffed, care providers struggle to maintain a person-centered approach. Tasks are often performed hastily, leaving little time for the meaningful interactions that are critical for the well-being and dignity of residents. There may not be the staff numbers to facilitate meaningful activities. Staff who are exhausted and burnt out may not be as attentive or responsive to residents’ needs, which has a cascading impact on residents’ physical and emotional health.
Burnout and morale: The human cost of high turnover
The constant cycle of turnover also takes a profound toll on the emotional well-being of staff. For both managers and carers, covering shifts, navigating the unpredictable demands of care work, and dealing with the resulting exhaustion can be mentally taxing. Studies indicate that the relentless demands of staffing shortages lead to high levels of stress and burnout. Burnout is a particular concern, as it affects not only employees’ job performance but also their overall health and quality of life.
My research found that 75% of managers worked beyond their contracted hours to fill gaps caused by staffing shortages. The emotional toll this takes on them is significant. Many managers report experiencing symptoms of depression and anxiety due to the stress of managing chronic understaffing, while carers also report high levels of stress, leading to sleep disturbances, anxiety, and a sense of isolation. Staff often express feelings of guilt for needing time off, fearing that their absence will exacerbate the staffing crisis. This guilt, combined with the relentless pressures of the job, leaves staff at all levels feeling trapped, powerless, and ultimately unsatisfied.
Financial constraints and limited resources
Financial restrictions play a significant role in fuelling the turnover cycle within social care. Due to constrained budgets, care providers may lack the resources necessary to adequately compensate staff or improve working conditions. Many care homes are unable to offer competitive salaries or benefits compared to other sectors, making recruitment and retention especially challenging. As a result, many care workers leave in pursuit of better-paying jobs with better work-life balance, further depleting the already strained workforce. This creates a “revolving door” effect where new hires are difficult to attract, and experienced workers are hard to retain.
A lack of resources also impacts training opportunities for staff, contributing to skill gaps within the workforce. Care workers who do not receive adequate training may feel ill-equipped to handle the demands of their roles, leading to further dissatisfaction and turnover. Without proper training, the quality of care can also suffer, creating additional stress for staff who may feel unprepared to meet the complex needs of residents.
Organisational culture: The role of leadership in breaking the cycle
Effective leadership and a positive organisational culture can make a significant difference in breaking the cycle of staff turnover in social care. Managers have a crucial role in shaping the work environment, promoting employee well-being, and building a supportive team culture. When leaders demonstrate empathy, flexibility, and commitment to staff well-being, employees are more likely to feel valued and supported, which can increase job satisfaction and retention.
However, managers in understaffed facilities often find themselves with little time to focus on creating a supportive culture. The pressures of dealing with staffing shortages, coupled with a lack of autonomy and flexibility from senior leadership, create an environment where it is difficult to prioritise employee support. Managers frequently express frustration with micromanagement and rigid operational guidelines that prevent them from making the necessary adjustments to better support their teams.
A more flexible approach to leadership—one that allows managers to adjust workloads, offer mental health resources, and establish open lines of communication—can help reduce burnout and improve morale. Additionally, fostering a culture of transparency, where managers and staff can openly discuss challenges and seek solutions, can empower employees to remain engaged and committed to their work, even during difficult times.
Breaking the cycle: Recommendations for social care providers
To address the root causes of high staff turnover in social care, a comprehensive approach is necessary. Here are some key strategies that can help social care providers break the cycle of turnover and create a more sustainable work environment:
1. Prioritise staff well-being and workplace culture
- Leadership should actively focus on creating a positive and supportive workplace culture. This includes regularly checking in with staff, addressing their concerns, and making small, meaningful improvements to their daily work environment (e.g., improving amenities, recognising achievements, providing nice coffee).
- Introduce well-being programs that address mental health, work-life balance, and stress management, ensuring that staff feel valued and supported.
2. Establish clear operational support during staffing crises
- Create clear protocols for managing during times of crisis, ensuring that managers receive non-judgmental and practical support. This may include temporarily adjusting care standards, focusing on safety and basic care, and providing extra administrative help to reduce managerial burdens.
- Create a pool of temporary staff (bank staff) a pool of trained, temporary staff who can step in during shortages can provide immediate relief to understaffed facilities.
3. Invest in Training and Development
- Despite staffing shortages, invest in ongoing training and development for all levels of staff. This includes prioritising short, targeted training sessions that can be conducted during shifts to avoid disruption to care delivery.
- Training should also include mental health resources and resilience-building techniques to help staff cope with job-related stress.
- Enhance supportive leadership and organisational culture.
- Leadership should provide managers with greater autonomy to make decisions that best support their teams, including adjusting deadlines, reallocating resources, or temporarily pausing non-essential tasks to focus on staff well-being.
- Ensure that senior managers remain available to provide hands-on support in times of crisis, helping managers plan and relieve operational pressures.
5. Investment in Technology
- Care settings should invest in technology that supports managers in streamlining their work. Systems for managing staffing schedules, tracking resident care, and maintaining compliance can reduce administrative burdens and allow managers to focus more on leading their teams and supporting staff.
6. Advocate for policy reforms and increased funding
- The challenges faced by the social care sector require systemic solutions. Advocacy for increased funding and policy reforms is essential to address the underlying causes of workforce shortages and improve working conditions within social care. Government bodies and policymakers must work alongside care providers to implement changes that address the sector’s financial constraints and workforce needs.
Conclusion: Moving toward sustainable social care
The high turnover rate in social care is more than a staffing issue; it is a cycle that impacts the well-being of workers and the quality of care provided. Addressing this challenge requires a concerted effort from care providers, policymakers, and society at large. With increased funding, supportive leadership, and systemic reforms, social care providers can build a more resilient workforce, capable of delivering high-quality care to the most vulnerable.
By prioritising worker well-being and creating a supportive work environment, the social care sector can begin to break free from the damaging turnover cycle, ensuring a future where both staff and service users can thrive.
Images: Susanne Jeffries and Armin Lotfi
In related news: